Amy Cain

Amy C.

Columbus, OH
100% Satisfaction Guarantee

100% Satisfaction Guarantee

We know that starting lessons is a big step and we want you to feel confident booking with us. If you are not completely satisfied, we'll help you find a new teacher or you can receive a refund for any unused lessons within the first year from the date of purchase.

Lesson Details

See all subjects

Amy teaches



Amy passed a background check that includes a SSN verification, national criminal record check, and sex offender registry search. Learn More
Amy delivers an exceptional lesson experience and ranks in the top 15% of our teachers nationwide.
Teaches students:
Ages 4+ and special needs

Teaching since:
September 2010

Are you interested in learning piano, or do you have a child who is? I can't wait to help you turn this desire into reality! My name is Amy, and I am a piano teacher who specializes in teaching children. I descend from a long line of musicians (both my mother and grandmother were piano teachers) and have played piano for 21 years, studying with a private instructor for 13 of those. I received my BFA at Goddard College (’14) and my MFA at Boston University (’16).

Over the past seven years I have taught piano to students of all ages and levels in Ann Arbor, Michigan, Boston, Massachusetts, and now Columbus! I am currently accepting students for the Winter 2018 Semester! As a member of the Ohio Music Teacher’s Association, I can offer your child multiple performance opportunities throughout the year, as well as small group lessons in my studio. Learning an instrument is beneficial for many reasons. Aside from the obvious enjoyment one gets out of playing beautiful music, working at a skill week after week helps children build confidence and grow in all areas of life. I coach my students to take pride in their accomplishments, to exude an air of assurance and poise when sitting at the piano, and to become self-directed learners.

One of the wonderful (and obvious) benefits of private instruction is that each student's unique abilities and shortcomings can be brought into clear focus and addressed. I am highly skilled at encouraging students through a careful balance of praise and constructive criticism. I make sure they are aware of (and take pride in) their strengths so that when challenging moments arise, they are motivated to do the work.

I maintain high expectations for my students, constantly reminding them that it's the quality (not the quantity) of their playing that counts. It is much more important to me that a student learns to play one piece well rather than ten pieces poorly. There is no race to the finish line. I believe in taking however much time is necessary to help a child understand a concept—we might spend the majority of a lesson on it if we have to. Learning must be done at the child's own speed. Children benefit enormously from having 100% of my attention during lessons; they will never need to try and "catch up" with other students.

Most method books for young students focus on teaching the child to read notes on a page, and as one can only learn to read music so fast, children are therefore stuck playing songs that keep the hands rooted on or around Middle C. There are so many problems with this method, least of all the fact that it's quite boring. A bigger issue is the lack of focus on technique and playing. Children are naturally musical--they love to sing and dance. Playing piano should be no different. Children can be taught songs using no music at all; rather, they can learn simple melodies by identifying patterns on the piano. This helps train their ear AND frees the child up to focus on technique rather than scrutinizing the notes on the page. My students get to use the entire keyboard almost right away (both black keys and white keys) rather than being crowded around Middle C.

Another issue with the Middle C position is that it creates an awkward twisting inward of the wrists, which breeds tension. The first thing students should learn is how to play with relaxed wrists, not tense ones!! This is one of the building blocks of good piano technique. Keeping kids rooted around Middle C for the first six months of their piano education does not set them up for good technique.

Now, all of this is not to say that I don't teach children to read music--I do. Absolutely! I introduce intervals and guide notes as soon as possible. I think the intervallic approach is super useful, especially when dealing with children who are coached from a young age to look for patterns. Alongside reading music, though, it is important to teach songs that are only for playing.

For beginning students, I like to use the Piano Safari method. These books offer a wonderful blend of rote pieces (for playing, not reading) and reading pieces that use the intervallic approach. These pieces are fun and engaging--some parents complain about how their children won't stop practicing them! Here is a sampling book of other books and materials I may use:

Beginning Students: Tales of a Musical Journey Books 1 + 2, Piano Safari Books 1 + 2, Carl Czerny's The Little Pianist, Bastien Piano Literature Book 1, Royal Conservatory Series Preparatory Books A & B and Book 1

Intermediate Students: Piano Safari Book 3, Bastien Piano Literature Books 2-4, Royal Conservatory Series Books 2-6

Advanced Students: Bastien Piano Literature Books 5-6, Early Advanced Classics to Moderns, Royal Conservatory Series Books 7-10

+ Read More


MFA in Creative Writing
Aug 2015 - Present
Boston University
BFA in Music & Creative Writing
Sep 2010 - Jul 2014
Goddard College


Limited Proficiency


Music Teachers National Association
Oct 2016

The MTNA was founded in 1876 with the goal of advancing the value of music study and music-making to society while supporting the careers and professionalism of teachers of music. With nearly 22,000 members in 50 states—and more than 500 local affiliates—the MTNA is the preeminent source for music teacher support, where members embody like-minded values and commitment to their students, colleagues and society as a whole, while reaping the rewards of collaboration, continuity and connection throughout the lifetime of their careers.

+ Read More

Photos & Videos

Mozart's Sonata in B-flat Major, K358, 1st Movement: Allegro, played by Amy and Cecile.
Amy's studio

Winter Recital 2015, Kerrytown Concert House, Ann Arbor, MI

Winter Recital 2017, Graves Piano & Organ, Columbus, OH

Spring Recital 2018, Graves Piano & Organ, Columbus, OH

Nico plays "The Calico Cat" by Helen Marlais
student plays "The Haunted Mouse" by Nancy & Randall Faber
Anthony plays I Love Coffee arr. Bernard & Carolyn Shaak
Nicolas & Isabella receive awards for their participation in the Royal Conservatory of Music exams in May 2018.
+ 2 more

12 Reviews

Write a Review
Frank B. Jul 19, 2018
Piano · In home

Extremely happy with her teaching method. I would highly recommend her.

Ali R. Jan 9, 2018
Piano · In studio

Very engaging first lesson! Ali is excited to continue.

Jasmine R. Nov 16, 2017
Piano · In home

We had our first piano lesson today and Amy was absolutely fantastic. My daughter left very excited and looking forward to her next lesson.

Mickey M. Feb 23, 2017
Piano · In studio

Amy has been great. She adjusted quickly to my skill level (somewhere between beginner and intermediate), tailored what she taught me to my interests, and is generally very patient and helpful. She's skilled, knowledgable, and is great to work with!

Am Gi Sep 17, 2016

Amy is one of the best piano teachers you will ever find. She loves music and is able to pass that passion on to her students. She works with each one as a unique individual, no rote formula or one size fits all approach. We drive from Dayton to Columbus every week because it's worth it to have Amy as a teacher. I would recommend her anytime to anyone seeking quality, enjoyable music instruction.

+ Read More
Beth D. Sep 16, 2016
Piano ·

My 6 year old daughter takes lessons with Amy and it's been a wonderful experience. She is excited to show us what she's learned and really enjoys her lessons. She was very comfortable with Amy from the start and many times she is shy with new people. I would highly recommend her to anyone wanting to learn piano.

+ Read More
julie db Sep 16, 2016
Piano ·

My 6 years old daughter had a wonderful experience with Amy in Boston, MA. In general she has issues focusing on tasks, but Amy was always able to keep her attention and motivate her to do her best. Amy is very personable, professional and most of all patient, a very important skill to have when dealing with young students. She assigns homework and rewards students for it, helping them to practice with consistency and take pride of their accomplishments. I highly recommend Amy if you are in Columbus area and looking for a positive and enjoyable learning experience.

+ Read More
Kim Bonenberger Sep 15, 2016
Piano ·

Amy taught my children piano lessons in Ann Arbor, MI and I highly recommend her. The kids responded really well to her teaching and enjoyed the lessons. She focuses on posture, technique, has them play songs that they enjoy and can't say enough great things!

+ Read More
Meredith Smith Sep 15, 2016
Piano ·

My daughter just started lessons with Amy and she loves it. She has clicked with Amy and enjoys going to get lesson and wanting to practice to show Ms Amy how much she's learned. I would recommend Amy to anyone in the Columbus area looking for a piano teacher.

+ Read More
Isabella Sorvillo Sep 15, 2016
Piano ·

Amy is teaching my daughter her in Columbus and she is really really enjoying it. Amy makes it fun and has a great structure for piano lessons that allows her to enjoy practice and look forward to the fun - thank you!

Lindy Aug 24, 2016
Piano · In home

Amy is a wonderful teacher! She is very skilled and experienced, as well as very enthusiastic. My 6 year old son started with her and absolutely loved his lessons, and more importantly grew a love to play. Amy is reliable, flexible, makes the lessons both fun and technical and can tailor to your preferred kind of music.

+ Read More
Samantha Oct 2, 2015
Piano · In home

Amy is kind, organized, and has a diligent, positive approach.

You may want to revisit

Previously viewed teachers: